I normalised the index values (on the Y
axis) from the start of their decline in order to compare the
development in each time period with each other. The X axis shows the
number of trading days.
Total declines from its highest to
lowest point were as follows:
-
-
-
2007 -53% (Prices up to 22 June
2009)
As can be seen, depending on what
happens next, we have done relatively well compared to 1929 and worse
than 1973.
Assuming the worse case scenario, that
we have a replay of the crash of 1929 and the following bear market
what are we in for?
After examining the stock market's
behaviour during the 1930s, it looks like a replay will not be as
dreadful as it seems at first.
Purely looking at the index values it
took 25 years to 23 November 1954, from its high, for the DJII to
recover its losses from the high reached on 3 September 1929.
The reason for the significantly
shorter recovery period was two fold:
-
One was dividends, which were in
the double digits during the 1930s. Ignoring dividends, which is
what investors do when focusing on price alone, therefore,
introduces a significant pessimistic bias into any historical
analysis.
-
The other factor was deflation.
The consumer price index dropped by 27% between its high in 1929
and its low in 1933. A decline of less than this amount in nominal
terms over this four year period, would have represented a gain in
inflation-adjusted terms.
That may not be good news if you are
hoping to recover your nominal bear market losses in just one or two
years. But it's a lot better than taking 25 years to recover your
losses.
If we still follow the results of the
1930 bear market what would have happened if we invested after the
market fell 50% from its high and held on for the next five years?
Again according to the calculations of
Professor Siegel, over the five-year period following a 50% drop from
the index high the stock market produced an yearly inflation-adjusted
total return of 7%.
But if you wanted to see those returns
you had to hold on through a 60% decline in the first five months
after buying.
I am not sure if I would have held
through such a decline.
But that just shows how quickly such
significant losses can be made up in the market.
Because of the macroeconomic impact on
the markets in 2008 and in Q1 2009 I have found it difficult to take
my focus away from macroeconomic trends to focus on individual share
valuation.
But with many companies now trading at
significantly lower prices, there is considerably less risk of
further large declines going forward, assuming the earnings power of
a company is not permanently damaged.
The difficult question however it to
determine to what extent the earnings power of a company has been
damaged as a result of recent events.
Also with the implosion of the
financial sector it is not easy to determine that the new normal
state of the world economy will be.
This along with record
high profit margins declining to normal is making it very
difficult to determine what normalised earnings will look like going
forward.
Will the increased use of no-name
consumer goods for example, persist when the economy recovers and
what will the impact be on the valuations brand name consumer goods
companies like Nestle, P&G and Unilever.
Have you signed up for my free weekly newsletter "Investing that makes sense" yet?
Sign up now and receive
articles like this in your inbox weekly.
And if you sign up now you will also receive a
10 page free bonus report - Enhanced Checklist for Value Investors - with over
30 proven checklist items to improve your investment returns.
I respect your privacy - Privacy
Policy
This uncertainty will however create
huge opportunities because of mispriced securities and the tendency
of the market the throw the baby out with the bathwater.
What all of this means to you and me:
-
Shares will be a good investment
from this level forward, but
-
You will have to have a long term
investment outlook of at least five years
-
Stock picking will be much more
important compared to index investing
-
We may experience mind numbing
declines in between that will test our resolve to the utmost
All in all interesting times.
Regards
Tim du Toit