|
Green shoots or getting worse more slowly? |
| Print | |
|
I have been meaning to write something
on the “green shoots” and sentiment driving the recovery of world
markets.
If nothing else to get my thinking
straight.
Objectivity has however proven to be
difficult as I am still firmly anchored in thinking that this is
still a bear market rally, especially with 88% of my portfolio in
cash.
I must admit that I am sometimes have
really strong feelings that I have missed the boat by not buying
anything at the March market lows.
There is nothing I hate more than
running after a share price when buying. This behaviour has cost me
more than care to calculate.
My impression, when looking at the
trend in most of the indicators mentioned below, is that the speed of
deterioration has slowed down. It is however a different matter to
say it has turned around or that it will turn positive soon.
The stock market also seems to have
decoupled from the world economy with the economy still
getting worse and the markets taking off.
I have used the time while waiting for
the market to come down to research strong companies that require no
access to the capital markets.
My shopping list is ready, waiting for
the right price.
I suggest you do the same:
-
Work through your list of potential buy candidates.
-
Determine at what price they will be really attractive.
-
Write the price and why its attractive down. This is important
because when markets are plunging it is difficult not to get swept up
in the negative sentiment.
-
Wait patiently for the price to come along
Below is list of the main articles I
have found providing some insight on the debate.
Scan through them
quickly to see if you missed any of the news items.
Contrary to all the market noise, there
are no signs of a significant economic recovery. So-called green
shoots in the global economy are mostly due to inventory cycles.Stimuli might juice up growth a bit in the second half 2009. Nothing,
however, suggests a lasting recovery. Markets are trading on
imagination.
While rational expectation is returning
to part of the investment community, most investors are still trapped
by institutional weakness, which makes them behave irrationally. The
Greenspan era has nurtured a vast financial sector. All the people in
this business need something to do. Since they invest other people's
money, they are biased toward bullish sentiment. Otherwise, if they
say it's all bad, their investors will take back the money, and they
will lose their jobs. Governments know that, and create noise to give
them excuses to be bullish.
This institutional weakness has been acatastrophe for people who trust investment professionals. In the
past two decades, equity investors have done worse than those who
held U.S. market bonds, and who lost big in Japan and emerging
markets in general. It is astonishing that a value-destroying
industry has lasted so long. The greater irony is that salaries in
this industry have been two to three times above what's paid in other
sector. The key to its survival is volatility. As markets collapse
and surge, possibilities for getting rich quickly are created.Unfortunately, most people don't get out when markets are high, as
they are now. They only take a ride.
This article “A Tale of Two
Depressions” by economists Barry Eichengreen and Kevin O’Rourke
shows, global industrial output is still on a similar trajectory as it
was during 1930's. This analysis shows individual countries and the
world graphically. The picture is not pretty.
Economies of Europe and the UK
I doubt if investors rushing into the
EUR 100bn of equity issuances in Europe so far this year are going to do
well. It may help the companies survive but as in the past with aglut of new issues, investors have inevitably done poorly. Goldman
Sachs calculates that the market has capacity to absorb EUR 400bn in
new issuances. My question is, if there really are green shoots why
are all these companies rushing to issue so much equity?
The European Central Bank’s June 2009
financial stability review, suggests Euro area banks have absorbed 60
per cent of losses estimated for 2007-2010. Saying $280bn of
estimated loan losses have yet to be written off. With most of
Europe’s biggest financial companies employing aggressive
accounting practices that may mask their true financial condition its
not going to be pretty going forward.
The president of the German Chamber of
Commerce and Industry (DIHK) said the German credit crunch is getting
worse. A DIHK survey found that credit terms are now tougher than
they were at the height of the global crisis over the winter.
Industrial production dropped 1.9% in
the Euro-zone (16 countries) in April from March and declined 21.6%
y-o-y. The month on month decline accelerated from February -1.4%
but was less than the Jan to Feb decline of -2.6%.
At least some encouraging news on house
prices stabilising in the UK. Valuators however have a negative
outlook and rising unemployment and rising interest rates are
unlikely to help.
German exports are still falling
against expectations. April was 4.8 per cent lower than in March, and
28.7 per cent down against a high April 2008 number. This is thesteepest annual fall since records began in 1950. Separately, the
economics ministry reported industrial production was down 1.9 per
cent in April compared to March. Economists expected a small increase.
“Germany will be down and out for a
long time with a huge and still unresolved banking crisis, an
overshooting exchange rate and lower net exports, presided over by
politicians who panic about domestic inflation. This will not end
well.”
The fears are mainly focused on Latvia,
which had a disastrous Q1 GDP decline of 18.6 per cent.
Swedish banks have claims in Latvia,
Lithuania and Estonia amounting to about $75 billion, according to
ING Groep NV, with SEB, Swedbank and Nordea accounting for 53 percent
of Latvia’s lending market.
“This leaves two European answers,
one likely but undesirable, the second unlikely but desirable. The
likely answer is that demand will be driven by unsustainable fiscal
expansions in post-bubble economies. The unlikely answer is that
private demand will pick up in creditworthy economies, particularly
Germany. In the absence of either, Europe will wait for the US to
spend itself back into (temporary) vigour. It is a sad picture,
whatever the “green shoots” may seem to show.”
US industrial production figures
recorded their 16th monthly drop in May. Industrial capacity
utilisation dropped to a record-low of 68.3 per cent with the
manufacturing figure came in at an even worse rate of 65 per cent.
Prior to this recession, the low for the series which began in 1948,
was 68.6 per cent set in December 1982.
Stephen Schork, energy market analyst
and author of the Schork report said:
“We have never come out of a
recession without a commensurate bounce in manufacturing.
Barrons puts the S&P 500 2008
historical PE at 130 times. Even with bank earnings recovering it
will be tough to make that up.
The number of property repossessions in
the USA is and remains at record levels. Even though there has been
some misreporting of repossessions and foreclosures the numbers
remain high. In May repossession rose 2 per cent,
month on month, as delays and moratoria on foreclosures implemented
by various state laws came to an end.
US Banks are still far from healthy in
spite of stress tests, repayment of government funding and capital
raising. Take a look at this article in the FT depicting thehealthiest US bank. As an investor, would you touch the following
bank with a cattle prod?
US exports are also not helping the
recovery. Exports in April fell 21 per cent year-on-year to theirlowest level since July 2006. Even supposedly more buoyant countries
are buying less. Exports to to China was down as well as to South and
Central America were down about 8 per cent.
The US consumer is still over leveraged
in spite of the Q1 savings rate increasing to 5.4% the highest level
in 14 years. So much for an expected increase in consumer spending.
In this freight volume chart
also the FT show that the US economy is not yet bottoming out. The decline
in volumes is actually accellerating.
“Freight volumes are still trending
lower. The year-on-year deficit has widened from minus 14 per cent
at beginning of March to minus 18 per cent at the beginning of Apr,
minus 21.6 per cent at the beginning of May and and then minus 23.5
per cent at the start of June. “
The NYT said that loan quality at
American banks is the worst in at least a quarter century, and the
quality of loans is deteriorating at the fastest pace ever, according
to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
Credit card loss rates have tracked the
unemployment rate but that relationship has been breaking down for
more troubled credit card portfolios, such as the $25.9bn in WaMu
credit card loans. At the end of the first quarter, 12.63% of WaMu
credit card loans were deemed uncollectable by JPMorgan. Where does
that leave Citi and other large banks with large portfolios and loose
credit morals?
“We’re about to have a big problem.
Foreclosures were bad last year? It’s going to get worse.”
-Morris A. Davis, a real estate expert
at the University of Wisconsin.
It is unlikely that Chine and Japanese
stimulus spending is going to help the world pull out of the economic
nosedive as imports continue to plunge. Hardly a hopeful sign of
boosting demand elsewhere in the world.
Furthermore already high Japanese debt
levels also make it doubtful as to how long they can continue
stimulating.
Asian economic health continues to
decline in May. China’s official purchasing managers’ index fell
from the month before. Exports from Korea dropped 28 per cent
year-on-year, worse than expected and a steeper decline than April’s
19 per cent.
Have you signed up for my free weekly newsletter "Investing that makes sense" yet?
Sign up now and receive
articles like this in your inbox weekly.
And if you sign up now you will also receive a
10 page free bonus report - Enhanced Checklist for Value Investors - with over
30 proven checklist items to improve your investment returns.
I respect your privacy - Privacy
Policy
Baltic beach holiday and seminar in southern Italy
In the week of July 6 Nikki and I am taking Nikki's godchild to
the Baltic sea for a week of windsurfing. It the weather does not get
better he will have to live in a wetsuit.
I remain confident that summer will arrive on time. Hope springs eternal!
On 14 and 15 July I will attend my fourth Value Investing Seminar in Italy.
I am really looking forward to the great food, presentations and
discussions. Its the third time I will attend and I will not miss it
for the world. Details can be found by clicking here
Regards
Tim du Toit
P.S. A media company in the wrong country at the wrong time...

This month the company I found for subscribers is located in France.
In terms of the size of companies I look at its quite large with a market value of €1,72 billion.
The company owns the most popular television channel in one of the largest European countries but is also very active in new media channels including the internet, tablets and smart phones.
In spite of this, the market views it as an old media company that is soon going the way of the dinosaurs. However, when you look at its financial statements you will see what a great business it is.
Its balance sheet is solid with no debt, and it generates a high amount of free cash flow and profits. This enables it to pay a dividend of just under 7% that can easily be maintained and has room to increase.
When I recommended the company it was trading at 7 times free cash flow, 7,7 times 2010 earnings and 5,6 times EBIT to enterprise value.
I am sure you will agree this is undervalued.
To immediately get your hands on this value investment idea (for as little as €39) click here.
|
|